FOS decisions / Catalogue Credit
Catalogue Credit
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
39
Upheld
16
Not upheld
23
Avg redress
£175
Upheld complaints (16)
Frasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-6197105A lender must conduct reasonable and proportionate checks before increasing a credit limit to ensure the consumer can repay in a sustainable way.
UpheldFeb 2026Frasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-6046390A lender must conduct proportionate affordability checks before approving credit and credit limit increases, with the level of checks tailored to the credit amount and circumstances.
UpheldDec 2025Shop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-5422273A lender must apply a default notice within three to six months of arrears accruing, and should not apply interest or charges after the default date, even when the consumer has health difficulties.
UpheldRedress £100Mar 2025Frasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5322411A credit provider must properly administer billing disputes and ensure correct billing, even when goods are supplied by a third party retailer.
UpheldRedress £200Frasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5344670A lender must carry out proportionate affordability checks before increasing a customer's credit limit to ensure the customer can repay the increased amount sustainably.
UpheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5387785Lenders must carry out proportionate affordability checks and consider the information obtained to make fair lending decisions, ensuring repayments can be sustained without causing financial hardship.
UpheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5421061A lender must carry out proportionate checks to ensure lending is sustainable, taking into account the consumer's income, expenditure, and ability to repay without undue financial strain.
UpheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5472002Lenders must conduct reasonable and proportionate affordability checks that are borrower-focused, considering the consumer's ability to sustainably repay credit, especially as credit limits increase over time.
UpheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5404405Lenders must carry out proportionate affordability checks and consider the information obtained to make fair lending decisions, not lending to those in financial hardship or where repayments cannot be sustained.
UpheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-5537746A catalogue credit provider is liable for failures in order processing and must ensure the consumer is charged only for goods actually retained, plus compensation for distress caused by service failures.
UpheldRedress £265Shop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-5748560Lenders must carry out reasonable and proportionate affordability checks to ensure credit is sustainable, considering the borrower's overall financial circumstances and debt-to-income ratio.
UpheldJ D Williams & Company Limited
DRN-5671878A lender must have reasonable evidence that an applicant authorised a credit account before pursuing them for the debt, considering the balance of probabilities where evidence is incomplete or contradictory.
UpheldRedress £50Shop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-5793475A lender must conduct proportionate affordability checks before providing credit and limit increases, and the overall lending relationship must not be unfair to the consumer under s140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974.
UpheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5778092A lender's liability for disputed goods under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 requires the item to cost between £30,000 and £100, and failure to meet these conditions means the lender has no duty to intervene in the supplier disp
UpheldRedress £50J D Williams & Company Limited
DRN-5922765A lender must conduct proportionate affordability checks that are borrower-focused, assessing both ability to repay and the sustainability of repayment on the consumer's circumstances.
UpheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6011343When compensating for irresponsible lending, the compensation should offset the outstanding balance owed rather than be paid directly to the consumer, as this approximates the position the consumer would have been in had the lender not lent
UpheldRedress £637
Not-upheld complaints (23)
Home Retail Group Card Services Limited
DRN-6193342A financial provider must inform consumers of missed payments in a timely manner, even if not contractually obligated to do so, as good industry practice.
Not upheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5784925A creditor must carry out proportionate affordability checks before providing credit or increasing limits, or the lending relationship may be found unfair under s140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974.
Not upheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5922101A lender must complete reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before offering credit, including verification of income and assessment of non-discretionary spending.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6080559A lender must conduct reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before agreeing credit, with proportionality determined by the amount of credit and consumer's circumstances.
Not upheldFreemans Public Limited Company
DRN-6094371A lender must complete proportionate checks to ensure a consumer can afford to sustainably repay credit, with proportionality depending on the amount and term of lending and what the lender already knows.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6024907A lender must carry out reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before providing revolving credit, based on sufficient information available at the time of assessment.
Not upheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5833533A creditor's lending relationship with a consumer may be unfair under s140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 if it failed to conduct appropriate affordability checks that would have revealed lending was unaffordable or irresponsible.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6110564A lender may fairly report accurate missed payment information to credit reference agencies where the payment was genuinely not made by the due date, even if the reason for non-payment was due to third-party error.
Not upheldFrasers Group Financial Services Limited
DRN-5817421Lenders must carry out reasonable and proportionate checks before lending that assess the borrower's ability to afford and sustainably repay the credit without financial harm.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6207724A lender must carry out proportionate checks to ensure credit is provided responsibly and that repayment would be sustainable.
Not upheldNext Retail Limited
DRN-6148907A creditor's lending decisions may create an unfair relationship under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 if proportionate affordability checks would have revealed the borrower could not afford the credit.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6138385Lenders must carry out proportionate affordability checks before agreeing to increase credit limits, considering the borrower's income, expenditure, and ability to repay sustainably.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6124646A lender must carry out proportionate checks to assess affordability and sustainability of credit, considering the type, amount, duration and cost of credit alongside the borrower's individual circumstances.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6035981Lenders must carry out proportionate affordability checks appropriate to the type and amount of credit before lending and must fairly consider the information obtained to make responsible lending decisions.
Not upheldNext Retail Limited
DRN-6097917A creditor must carry out proportionate affordability checks to ensure sustainable repayment and avoid creating an unfair credit relationship under Section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-6190551A lender must carry out reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before lending, and must not create an unfair credit relationship by failing to do so when this would have revealed irresponsible or unaffordable lending.
Not upheldFreemans Public Limited Company
DRN-6178754A creditor may lawfully default an account when a consumer fails to maintain an agreed payment plan and remains in sustained arrears, provided it complies with ICO guidance on timing.
Not upheldShop Direct Finance Company Limited
DRN-5998259A lender must take reasonable steps to ensure it does not lend irresponsibly, and the fairness of a lending relationship must be assessed having regard to the whole history of the relationship under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1
Not upheldNext Retail Limited
DRN-6000211A complaint about unfair lending relationships under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 can be made within a reasonable timeframe even if individual lending decisions occurred more than six years prior, provided the complaint is f
Not upheldJ D Williams & Company Limited
DRN-6024130Lenders must carry out proportionate affordability checks considering the type, amount, duration and total cost of credit, and must assess whether the borrower can repay sustainably without financial difficulties.
Not upheldJ D Williams & Company Limited
DRN-6126681A lender must complete proportionate affordability checks before agreeing credit and limit increases, considering the amount, term, and what is already known about the consumer.
Not upheldNext Retail Limited
DRN-6154856A lender's relationship with a borrower is unfair under s140A Consumer Credit Act 1974 if it fails to conduct reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before lending or increasing credit limits.
Not upheldNext Retail Limited
DRN-6045747A lender should not record a default while a temporary payment arrangement is being maintained and the consumer is keeping to agreed payments, as a default reflects breakdown of the relationship between parties.
Not upheld